South Korea's duty-free sales hit a record in 2017 despite the Chinese group tour ban
Beijing's halt on group tours emptied the tour buses in Seoul for most of 2017. The duty-free tills had their best year ever, and Chinese shoppers were still the reason.
2 min read
South Korea’s licensed duty-free shops sold goods worth about 14.5 trillion won (roughly $13.6 billion) in 2017, according to figures from the Korea Duty Free Shops Association. That was an increase of close to 18 percent on the 12.3 trillion won recorded in 2016 and the highest total the industry has reported.
The record came in the worst year for Chinese tourism to Korea in a long time. In March 2017 Chinese travel agencies stopped selling package tours to South Korea, a move widely read as a response to Seoul’s decision to deploy the American THAAD missile defense system. Figures from the Korea Tourism Organization show about 3.8 million Chinese arrivals in the first eleven months of the year, 49.1 percent fewer than in the same period of 2016. China’s share of all foreign arrivals dropped from 47.4 percent to 31.4 percent, and total foreign arrivals fell by 23.3 percent.
Who was buying
The answer to the puzzle is the daigou, the traveling personal shoppers who buy cosmetics, skin care and luxury goods abroad and resell them to customers in China. A customs official quoted by the Yonhap news agency put the sales growth down to small-scale Chinese traders, who kept coming while the tour groups stayed home. Many make repeated short trips to Seoul, fill their bags in the downtown duty-free stores and fly back the same week.
That makes the record less impressive than it looks. Duty-free operators competing for these bulk buyers pay commissions and offer discounts to the agents who bring them in, so revenue grew faster than profit. The wider tourism economy gained even less. A reseller on a buying trip spends little on hotels, restaurants or sightseeing. The money that used to flow from Chinese tour groups to coach companies, guides and restaurants did not come back with the daigou.
What the record does say
The sales figures do show that demand in China for Korean products held up through a year of heavy official pressure, which fell hardest on companies such as Lotte, the conglomerate that supplied the land for the THAAD site. Consumers who could not join a tour still wanted Korean cosmetics badly enough to pay a middleman to fetch them.
In late November 2017 the authorities let travel agencies in Beijing and Shandong province sell group tours to South Korea again, though only through offline channels. A full reopening would bring back the leisure travelers who stay longer and spend across the whole economy. If that happens, Korea’s duty-free retailers may find that the most profitable year in their history is still ahead.
Since then, China kept most of the restrictions in place for years and restored group tours to South Korea only in August 2023.