Skip to the page

Passport Season

Notes on how China travels

Destinations

China Widens Its Curbs on Group Tours to Taiwan

Nothing has been announced, but group tours to Taiwan are being squeezed again, with local elections, a U.S. law and an earthquake all cited as reasons.

3 min read

South Korea may soon have company. Beijing appears to be tightening travel to Taiwan again, after several months in which mainland arrivals on the island had picked up enough to prompt talk of a softer policy.

As with South Korea last year, the measure is closer to a quiet squeeze than a formal ban. Nothing has been published. In practice, the curbs fall on group tours, which make up a large part of leisure travel from the mainland, while independent trips, and with them business travel, carry on as before. The effect is to withhold the most lucrative kind of visitor from a place whose conduct Beijing objects to.

First South Korea, then the Vatican, now Taiwan

Chinese leisure travelers now spend enough abroad that limiting them costs the receiving country real money, a lesson learned in South Korea, where group tours stopped in March 2017 after Seoul agreed to deploy the American THAAD missile defense system. Late last year Chinese travel agencies were also told to stop selling tours to Palau and the Vatican, neither of which recognizes Beijing. Seen as trade, tourism is an import China buys in large quantities, particularly from neighbors such as Japan, South Korea, Thailand and Taiwan, and restricting it is a lever that needs no tariff schedule.

What is known so far

According to Taiwanese press reports, Beijing may hold mainland tour groups to 311,000 travelers between April and September and then stop group travel altogether from October to December. The Taipei Times quoted Wu Pi-lian, co-president of Cheng An Travel Service, as saying there might be no more mainland tour groups at all this year. Other local reports say the mainland authorities have stopped issuing Taiwan travel permits to tour groups.

With no statement from Beijing, the severity of the measure is hard to judge. Reports this month say China’s leading online travel agencies have stopped selling group tours to Taiwan that depart after June, although Taiwan remains listed and independent packages are still on sale. That is a milder picture than South Korea’s, which vanished from many Chinese booking sites entirely.

The trend was already downward. Taiwan’s Tourism Bureau, which publishes arrivals by country of residence, counted more than four million visitors from the mainland in 2015 and fewer in each year after; Beijing’s own Taiwan Affairs Office put the 2016 fall at close to 800,000.

No single trigger

The reason is harder to pin down than in South Korea’s case. Several issues are in play. Taiwan holds local elections on November 24, which falls inside the reported October to December halt, and Beijing has tended to restrict travel around Taiwanese elections before, as it did around the presidential and legislative votes of 2016. It is also wary of the governing Democratic Progressive Party, which leans toward independence, and group arrivals began to fall soon after the party took office in May 2016.

Washington is another factor. Both houses of the U.S. Congress have now passed the Taiwan Travel Act, which would encourage visits between American and Taiwanese officials at all levels. Beijing opposes the bill and says it breaches the One China principle.

Finally, the earthquake that struck Hualien on February 6 brought down buildings, including one containing a hotel, and visitors from the mainland were among the dead. Local media say the disaster, together with politics, lies behind the new limits.

Other markets are growing

Taiwan has some cushion. Arrivals from Japan, South Korea and Southeast Asia are rising, and the island received a record of more than 10.7 million visitors in 2017 despite the fall from the mainland. How long the new curbs last is anyone’s guess. South Korea is still waiting for its restrictions to end, and Beijing has no shortage of reasons to keep these in place.

Since then, Beijing has gone further, suspending on August 1, 2019, the program that let residents of 47 mainland cities visit Taiwan as individual travelers.