How many Chinese travelers visit Europe? Fewer than the headline numbers suggest
As the EU-China Tourism Year opens, the figures used to describe Chinese travel to Europe disagree with each other by a factor of two or more. Visa statistics tell a steadier and smaller story.
4 min read
The European Union has declared 2018 the EU-China Tourism Year, an EU-funded program to promote travel and cultural exchange between the member states and China. It rests on a simple premise: travelers from China are a large and growing source of revenue for Europe, and Europe should do more to attract them. There is an industry of consultants, guides and training courses built on the same premise, and in popular accounts Chinese visitors are often described as the most important group of tourists on the continent.
Measured against its geography, its cultural draw and its air links with China, Europe arguably underperforms. Before that can be judged, though, there has to be an answer to a basic question. How many travelers from China actually come to Europe each year?
Three numbers that cannot all be right
The published estimates do not agree. A Chinese state-funded outlet projected that about 5.5 million Chinese travelers would visit Europe in 2017. Material prepared for the EU-China Tourism Year put the number of Chinese tourists in Europe at 12 million as long ago as 2015. China’s State Council, meanwhile, reported that travel to Europe grew by about 65 percent year on year in the first half of 2017. A fall from 12 million to 5.5 million in two years, in a market said to be growing by two thirds a year, makes no sense.
Nor does life on the ground look like a market swinging by millions of people. Luxury retailers in Paris and Milan who sell to Chinese customers have not gone from record years to bankruptcy and back. Airlines flying between China and Europe forecast demand reasonably well and add capacity when it rises, to the extent that China’s aviation authorities grant them slots. Business, in short, has been fairly steady. The confusion lies in the statistics, and it matters, because public money for campaigns such as the Tourism Year is being allocated on the strength of them.
What the visa counts show
The most reliable data come from Brussels itself. The European Commission publishes the number of Schengen visas issued at every consulate, embassy and visa center of the member states. In 2016, 2,110,103 Schengen visas went to Chinese nationals. That covers the Schengen countries, which then included Norway, Iceland, Switzerland and Liechtenstein but not the United Kingdom, Ireland, Bulgaria, Croatia, Cyprus or Romania.
A visa is not a visit. Some are never used, and some holders of multiple-entry visas come more than once, so the number of trips is probably a little higher than the number of visas. It still means that about 2.1 million individual Chinese travelers had permission to enter the Schengen area in 2016.
The United States offers a way to convert visas into visits. The State Department issued 1,991,647 nonimmigrant visas to Chinese nationals in fiscal 2016, and the Commerce Department’s National Travel and Tourism Office recorded 2.97 million visits from China in 2016, about one and a half visits per visa. If the same ratio held in Europe, the Schengen countries would have received around 3.1 million visits from China. Adding Britain, which issues its own visas and recorded roughly 260,000 visits from China in 2016, brings the total to about 3.3 million. That may still be generous. The United States has a much larger Chinese diaspora and far more students from China, and both produce repeat visits.
Where the inflation comes from
The larger figures come from the way European countries count. In most of them, a visitor who spends at least one night is recorded as an arrival, even if that visitor entered the Schengen area somewhere else. A traveler who lands in Frankfurt, sleeps in Munich, crosses into Austria for two nights, continues to Italy and ends in Paris appears as an arrival in every one of those countries. Tour groups are the extreme case. A coach of 20 travelers on a ten-day circuit of five countries can produce 100 arrivals or more in the national statistics, and a continental total built by adding the national figures together multiplies the double counting.
None of the national numbers is false. Each country really did host those overnight visitors. But the sum is misleading, and it is the sum that appears in promotional material. If the United States counted the same way, recording a new arrival each time a visitor crossed a state line, its Chinese arrivals would be several times the three million it reports, and its lead over Europe would look larger still.
A realistic baseline
Official Chinese statistics are often treated with caution in Europe. The same caution is rarely applied to figures published by European institutions, yet on this question the European figure is the one furthest from what its own visa data show. If the Tourism Year is judged against a starting point of 12 million arrivals in 2015, it will look like a failure however well it goes.
A realistic baseline is around 3.3 million visits. That is not a disappointing number. A decade ago the Chinese outbound market barely reached Europe at all, and 3.3 million visitors with a strong appetite for shopping and sightseeing already represent a substantial business. It is also a number from which growth can be measured honestly.