Britain opens its skies wider to China, where America will not
London and Beijing have agreed to let half as many flights again operate between them. Washington, worried about its airlines, has shown no appetite for a similar step.
3 min read
Britain is looking for income that does not depend on its trade with the European Union, and visitors from China are one of the more promising sources. On December 10, Transport Secretary Chris Grayling announced an agreement with China to raise the number of passenger flights allowed between the two countries from 100 a week to 150. Grayling presented the deal as part of preparing Britain for a world after Brexit, with better access to markets in the Far East.
It is the second loosening in little more than a year. In October 2016 the two governments lifted the weekly cap from 40 to 100, removed the restriction that had confined flights to a handful of airports in each country, and allowed unlimited all-cargo services.
Why flight caps matter
Easier visas help a destination, but only if travelers can get there. When the number of flights between two countries is fixed by treaty, airlines cannot add services when demand rises, fares stay higher and new routes from regional cities rarely get started. Removing or raising caps lets carriers respond to demand, and the most valuable result is usually a direct route that did not exist before.
The British deal is not a full open skies agreement of the kind that abolishes limits altogether, but it moves a long way in that direction. The United States has signed such agreements with many partners but has not sought one with China. The concern in Washington is commercial. American carriers argue that Chinese airlines enjoy favorable treatment at their home airports, and freer access to the United States would hand the Chinese carriers more takeoff and landing slots at American airports without equivalent gains for American airlines in China. Britain’s aviation industry is smaller and has less to defend, and the government has decided the benefits outweigh the risk.
The Manchester example
Part of the reason is what has happened in the north of England. Hainan Airlines began flying between Manchester and Beijing in 2016, the first direct link between China and a British city outside London. A study by the consultancy Steer Davies Gleave, published in November by Manchester Airports Group, found that the route carried about 90,000 passengers in its first year, 15 percent more than forecast. Spending by visitors reached about £140 million, double the expected value, and exports from the region to China rose 265 percent to almost £200 million a month. The number of people from the north traveling to China rose by 40 percent.
Those results came in a part of the country that most Chinese visitors have tended to skip. Their itineraries usually center on London and the south. A direct flight gave Manchester, and the cities within reach of it, a share of a market that had largely passed them by.
Room to grow
Chinese travel to Britain is already rising quickly, helped by a weaker pound since the 2016 referendum. Government figures show 115,000 visits from China in the first half of 2017, 47 percent more than a year earlier, with spending up 54 percent to £231 million. Britain still sits outside the Schengen area, though, so a Chinese visitor needs a separate British visa, while one Schengen visa covers most of continental Europe on a single trip.
More flights will not solve the visa question. The new ceiling does give airlines room to open routes to other regional airports, and if they repeat even part of the Manchester result, the deal will have paid for itself. The United States has chosen to protect its airlines instead, and it will be possible to compare the two approaches within a few years.