After the coronavirus: why independent travelers from China will return before tour groups
Europe's 2020 season looks lost, but recovery will come in stages. Travelers who plan their own trips are likely to lead it, and groups to follow well behind.
3 min read
For Europe’s tourism businesses, the season ahead looks bleak. Borders are closed, flights between China and Europe have been cut to a handful, and nobody can say when they will return to normal. Recovery will come eventually, though, and when it does it is unlikely to arrive all at once. Some kinds of traveler will return far sooner than others.
For two decades, the tour group was the backbone of Chinese travel to Europe. The traveler who plans a trip alone, known in the trade as the free independent traveler or FIT, has been gaining ground for years, and there are good reasons to expect that segment to recover first and to set the direction afterward.
Two different markets
Group travel grew out of China’s rapid rise in incomes. A generation that had become prosperous wanted to see the world but often lacked foreign languages or confidence abroad, and the organized tour answered both problems. That segment has been slowing for several years. Its core customers are getting older, many have already seen the famous sights, and European group products have been shifting toward smaller, more customized tours.
Independent travel draws on a younger cohort, broadly those born after China’s economic opening at the end of the 1970s. Many are only children whose families put everything into their education, and they grew up with opportunities their parents could not have imagined. They have money to spend, often speak at least some English, and plan and book everything on a smartphone.
Why independents come back first
The first reason is regulatory. On January 27, China suspended all outbound group tours and package sales. Independent travel was sharply reduced as well, by border closures and flight bans abroad, but it was never formally prohibited. It will not need an official decision to restart. Group tours will.
The second is practical. Even after the suspension ends, operators will need weeks or months to rebuild itineraries, contract hotels and coaches, and fill departures. An independent traveler needs only a few taps on a phone. The China Tourism Academy has found that 43 percent of independent travelers from China book their trips within two weeks of leaving. Older travelers, who make up most of the group market, may also be more cautious about going abroad once borders reopen.
The third is commercial. The tourism industry generally prefers independent visitors. They tend to stay longer and spend across a wider range of businesses, while groups concentrate their spending in a few predetermined places, and their sudden arrival or disappearance puts heavy strain on those places. As independents lead the recovery, businesses will put more effort into reaching them, which will speed the shift further.
The trend was already under way
Australia shows the direction of travel. By the figures widely cited in the trade, independent travelers made up 44 percent of Australia’s visitors from China in 2012 and 61 percent by 2017. Europe has been slower. In the first half of 2019, about 70 percent of Ctrip’s bookings to Europe were still group tours. The pandemic is likely to narrow that gap quickly.
Reaching travelers who plan alone
Independent travelers cannot be reached through a tour operator, so a business has to reach them directly, and in China that means WeChat. Most people there do not use Instagram, Facebook, Google or WhatsApp. WeChat had about 1.1 billion monthly users in the second quarter of 2019 and handles everything from hotel bookings and flight check-in to taxis and translation.
There are two ways in. An official account suits larger organizations willing to publish and answer messages regularly. A mini program, a small application running inside WeChat, is built around products and services and can take bookings, issue coupons and sell directly. Either gives a destination or a business a place to tell its story in Chinese, and a way to be found by travelers planning their first trip after the crisis.