Skip to the page

Passport Season

Notes on how China travels

Museums and culture

High altitude, low authenticity: the National Gallery's Shenzhen pop-up

Western museums are racing to reach China's young art lovers. A show of copies at a record-breaking observation deck suggests that those audiences are harder to please than the brand partnerships assume.

2 min read

The observation deck at the top of Ping An Finance Centre, Shenzhen’s tallest building, has a world record to its name. In October Guinness World Records certified Free Sky, on the 116th floor, as the highest glass floor cantilevered observation deck anywhere, at 547.6 meters. The exhibition now installed up there is unlikely to win any prizes.

The masterpieces, more or less

At Free Sky is the latest venture of London’s National Gallery in China. Its walls carry a survey of the Western canon: Leonardo, Titian, Van Eyck, Monet and Van Gogh among others. Every one of the paintings is a reproduction. The originals remain in Trafalgar Square.

The display leans heavily on the photograph. The pictures hang in clean white boxes, a portrait of Van Gogh looks down from the ceiling, and visitors can pose among props that echo the paintings, including a low field of wheat and a vase of real sunflowers. As a set for selfies it works. As an art exhibition it has disappointed many who paid for a ticket. On Weibo and WeChat, local visitors complained that they had been charged to see copies, and one widely shared post lamented that Shenzhen so rarely gets an exhibition worth the money.

A crowded field

The gallery’s aim is understandable. Over the past two years Western museums have hurried to engage China’s young, culturally curious consumers, who spend generously on exhibitions, on museum products and on travel to see collections abroad. The Centre Pompidou opened a partnership venue with the West Bund Museum in Shanghai in November. The British Museum has built a strong retail business on Chinese e-commerce. Shanghai’s riverside West Bund and Beijing’s 798 district have taken most of this activity, but Shenzhen, a young and wealthy city with a growing appetite for culture, is a natural next target.

The National Gallery has been busy. Since it began working with the licensing firm Alfilo Brands in 2018 it has staged a small exhibition inside a Shanghai metro station, opened a pop-up shop in Guangzhou and sold products on Chinese e-commerce platforms. These activities extend the brand and sell merchandise without lending real paintings, which is costly and slow.

What the complaints say

The reaction in Shenzhen points to a shift that Western institutions should take seriously. Chinese gallery-goers in the big cities have now seen serious loan exhibitions from Paris, London and New York. They know the difference between a show and a photo opportunity, and they say so in public. A replica exhibition at a tourist attraction might once have passed as a novelty. Today it invites the obvious comparison with Dafen, the Shenzhen village known for its workshops of painted copies.

None of this will hurt the National Gallery much in London. But in a market where reputation spreads through social media within hours, the cost of a weak show is real. The audience the gallery wants to court in China is the same one that will decide, a few years from now, whether a trip to London includes an afternoon in Trafalgar Square.