The exhibition is you: how selfies are changing art in China
Leandro Erlich's optical illusions have filled the CAFA Art Museum in Beijing this summer. Critics call it a selfie show, while the museum says popularity is no threat to scholarship.
4 min read
A woman walks along the bottom of a swimming pool in full clothes. Sunlight falls through the water above her, the surface ripples, and she is perfectly dry. The illusion is Swimming Pool, the best-known work of the Argentine artist Leandro Erlich, and this summer it has drawn long lines in Beijing and filled Chinese social media feeds.
The piece is part of The Confines of the Great Void, Erlich’s largest solo exhibition to date, which opened on July 10 at the CAFA Art Museum of the Central Academy of Fine Arts and runs until August 25. Erlich is the first non-Chinese artist to take over the museum’s entire exhibition space, and the show fills all four floors as well as outdoor areas. For some visitors it is a second encounter. Swimming Pool, first shown at the Venice Biennale in 2001, is in the permanent collection of a contemporary art museum in Kanazawa, Japan, where some of the Beijing visitors first saw it.
Built for the camera
Erlich’s works invite people to step inside them. Staircase sets a stairwell on its side so that visitors appear to climb it while lying on the floor. Bâtiment lays the facade of a building flat on the ground beneath a huge tilted mirror, so that people lying on it seem to hang from windows and ledges; the Beijing version takes its storefronts from the shop houses of Chinatowns. Each piece only works when there are people in it, and each produces a photograph almost by itself. It is easy to see why the exhibition spread online so quickly.
That popularity has also brought criticism. One widely shared comment on Weibo said that the experience was more about watching the crowd than seeing the art. Critics have called it a wanghong exhibition, using the term for internet-famous attractions, a label now applied to shows that seem designed for social media first and reflection second. Fashion brands have taken up the format, with touring pop-up shows whose main purpose is to be photographed.
The weight of the academy
The criticism has an edge because of where the show is. The Central Academy of Fine Arts is one of the most prestigious art schools in China. Xu Beihong was its first president, and Xu Bing is among its graduates. Some critics feel an institution of that standing should not be chasing crowds, especially at a time when Chinese museums are taking on more commercial partnerships.
Zhang Zikang, the museum’s director, rejects the charge. He has said that internet fame is a measure of an exhibition’s popularity and does not mean a weakening of its academic value, and that the museum does not turn away the business opportunities popularity brings.
He has company among museum leaders in Beijing. Philip Tinari, director of the UCCA Center for Contemporary Art, has stressed that museums need to stay connected to young urban audiences on digital platforms, and that a large part of UCCA’s outreach is now built on collaborations with social platforms, influencers and newer kinds of marketing partner. UCCA’s own summer exhibition, Picasso: Birth of a Genius, with 103 works lent by the Musée national Picasso-Paris, drew more than 100,000 visitors in less than a month after opening in June.
A larger appetite
Erlich’s show is one example of a broader appetite. Interactive and immersive exhibitions have proved very attractive to younger Chinese audiences, from Random International’s Rain Room at the Yuz Museum in Shanghai to teamLab’s installation at TANK Shanghai this year. The crowds also point to growing demand for good art in the capital, Chinese and Western alike.
Qiu Zhijie, a contemporary artist and CAFA professor known for his conceptual ink maps, offered a different view on a recent panel about curatorial strategy. He argued that too much is being made of how viewers interact with artworks, and that an exhibition exists to encourage personal experience and independent thought.
Art, commerce and the line between them
Complaints about commercialization in Chinese art are not new. The 798 Art Zone in Beijing and the nearby district of Caochangdi have both moved toward retail and commerce over the years. E-commerce is now part of museum life too, with Alibaba’s Tmall working with a growing number of museums on wenchuang, the cultural and creative products based on their collections, which have become popular with young buyers.
CAFAM’s approach suggests that the line between serious contemporary art and commercial spectacle is blurring. That is not entirely bad. Even if much of the attention to Erlich’s work is superficial, contact with art of any kind can be a starting point, and a crowd that comes for a photograph may return for something else. Visitors have complained about the noise and the crush in the galleries, and museums will need to find ways of building lasting relationships with the people who come. The crowds, and the commercial opportunities that come with them, are likely to stay.