Ctrip's chairman says China needs more museums and easier visas to win foreign visitors
The country that sends the most tourists abroad receives surprisingly few. At a conference built around outbound travel, the chairman of China's largest online travel agency spoke about the other direction.
2 min read
ITB China, held in Shanghai from May 16 to 18, is a trade show about Chinese people traveling abroad. James Liang, the co-founder and executive chairman of Ctrip, used his keynote there to talk about the opposite flow. His subject was why so few foreigners visit China, and what the government could do about it.
A lopsided balance
China is the world’s biggest source of outbound tourists and of tourism spending abroad, yet it attracts fewer international visitors than its size would suggest. Liang’s slides put China’s international arrivals in 2017 at 29.17 million. He set that against 75.1 million for the United States, 39.9 million for Turkey, 37.61 million for the United Kingdom and 28.69 million for Japan. Among the large countries he compared, only India, with 14.57 million, did worse, and relative to population even that gap is small.
He then went through the areas where China and the United States differ most. On his figures China ranks 177th for air quality against tenth for the United States. It offers visa exemptions to 14 countries where the Americans offer them to 38. China has 218 airports to 5,136 in the United States, and 4,873 museums against 35,144. Both America and Japan have many times more golf courses. China did come out ahead in ski resorts and in heritage sites.
Visas first
Of all these, Liang singled out visa policy as the main obstacle. One slide ranked China among the most restrictive countries in the world for visitors, with only Nigeria, Gabon, Pakistan, Angola and Saudi Arabia judged stricter. He suggested that national pride plays a part. Beijing has tended to offer visa-free entry only on a reciprocal basis, and many countries still require Chinese citizens to apply for visas in advance.
His counterexample was Turkey, which according to his figures exempts travelers from 78 countries from visas and drew close to 40 million visitors in 2017, more than ten million above China. In his reading, Turkey had decided that open doors were worth more to its tourism industry than strict reciprocity.
The case for museums
His other recommendations were more airport construction and further development of rail travel, alongside the visa reform. But the point that stood out in a conference hall full of travel sellers was cultural. Golf courses may have little effect on whether foreigners visit, Liang allowed, but museums do. A country with roughly four times the population of the United States has about one museum for every seven American ones, and he argued that this deficit makes China harder to sell as a destination for culture, whatever the depth of its history.
The argument has an obvious commercial side. Ctrip is expanding abroad under its Trip.com brand, and a China that more foreigners want to visit would bring business in both directions. It also fits a policy shift already under way. In March the government merged the tourism administration and the culture ministry into a single Ministry of Culture and Tourism, a sign that Beijing now sees museums, heritage and visitors as one portfolio.
Since then, China has begun waiving visas unilaterally for a growing list of countries, starting with France, Germany, Italy, the Netherlands, Spain and Malaysia on December 1, 2023.