Cruise lines grapple with a shaky Chinese market
After years of rapid growth, cruise lines in China are pulling ships and rethinking how they sell. The industry's own diagnosis covers prices, charters and a map with too few destinations.
2 min read
This has been a difficult year for cruising in China. Cruise Industry News estimates, based on ship deployments and announcements, that capacity in the Chinese market has fallen by about 14 percent from 2017 and will shrink by a further 4.4 percent in 2019. Lines that moved ships to Chinese ports expecting steady growth have been moving some of them elsewhere.
The industry is not giving up on China. Its potential customers number in the millions, the middle-class households that fill cruise ships around the world are growing in number and spending power, and some brands, Royal Caribbean among them, are already well known. At the China Cruise Shipping Conference in Shenzhen at the start of November, executives described the downturn as a temporary period of transition. They also agreed that the market needs restructuring before growth can return.
Price wars
The first problem is pricing. With more berths than buyers, lines have cut fares to fill ships, and price competition has wiped out most of the profit in the Chinese market. Companies hope that new pricing arrangements will bring some stability.
The charter model breaks down
The larger challenge is distribution. Chinese cruises have long been sold through charters, in which travel agencies or companies buy an entire ship or a large block of cabins and resell them. This year charters fell steeply, although executives gave few figures. Tong Jiangfeng, the chief port operations officer of Royal Caribbean International, said at the conference that his company had few charters this year and expected none next year, and that it needs a wider range of sales channels.
That means reaching smaller groups directly, especially families. Today those bookings come mostly through traditional travel agencies. Online travel agencies are a more stable long-term channel, and lines will need a stronger presence on them. Several executives also argued that quality should come before volume, because the Chinese market is not big enough to sustain large numbers of cheap, low-margin cruises.
Too few ports
The map is the third problem. Most cruises from China sail along the coast to call at ports in South Korea and Japan. Since March 2017, when Beijing stopped the sale of group tours to South Korea, Korean ports have largely dropped out, and lines have had to send ships to Japan or cancel routes.
Adding ports in Southeast Asia would help. Beach stops in Vietnam or the Philippines might sell better than another call in Korea or Japan, and they would give Chinese passengers something closer to the tropical cruises North Americans take in the Caribbean. But geography gets in the way: from Shanghai or Tianjin those ports are too far for the short cruises Chinese passengers prefer, and they are better served from Hong Kong. New agreements with ports in Southeast Asia will also take time to negotiate. A more varied set of itineraries is probably several years away.