Are cruises already falling out of favor with Chinese tourists?
Cruising was supposed to be the next big thing in Chinese outbound travel. At the start of 2018, the forecasts point down instead.
3 min read
As growth in international air travel out of China slowed from the double-digit rates of earlier years, cruising looked like the next frontier. Outbound travel as a whole was growing at roughly the pace of the economy. Cruising was growing far faster: by about 70 percent a year between 2013 and 2016, according to Goldman Sachs, which has advised several of the major lines on China. The industry responded accordingly. Cruise companies signed joint ventures and partnerships with Chinese firms, moved ships to Shanghai and Tianjin, and ordered new vessels designed for Chinese passengers.
Official targets were still ambitious. The Ministry of Transport in Beijing has set a goal of 4.5 million cruise passengers a year by 2020, against about 2.8 million in 2017. That would be close to a doubling, but spread over three years it implies a much slower pace than before. For comparison, CLSA expects total outbound trips from China to reach 200 million by 2020, up from 122 million in 2016, while the China National Tourism Administration puts the figure lower, at 150 million.
The first decline
Even the slower target now looks optimistic. The Financial Times reports that Chinese cruise passenger numbers are set to fall by about 14.3 percent in 2018, from 2.8 million to 2.4 million, a contraction in a travel market that is otherwise still expanding. The same report says Princess Cruises is taking two of its China-based ships out of the market altogether, and Royal Caribbean’s Mariner of the Seas is also being moved away from China. The downturn is a setback for the lines, and also for the Chinese government, which has promoted a domestic cruise and shipbuilding industry as a strategic project.
No single cause explains it. Regulation, politics and pricing have all pushed in the same direction.
Too many ships, too little margin
In the boom years, lines moved vessels to China, refitted others for Chinese tastes and began building ships for the market. The result is overcapacity. Ships with only light adaptation for Chinese passengers are the first to leave, and the rest compete on price.
Distribution makes this worse. Chinese rules limit the ability of foreign cruise companies to sell cabins directly to consumers, so most tickets are sold in bulk through travel agencies and online platforms, which are fiercely competitive and highly sensitive to price. Revenue per passenger in China has ended up well below what the same ships earn in other markets. Strong demand might have absorbed that pressure. Demand has turned out weaker than expected.
A product that resembles a tour group
Tastes have also moved. More travelers from China are planning their own trips instead of joining organized groups, and a cruise has a lot in common with a tour group: a fixed itinerary, set meal times, a limited range of activities and several days in the company of fellow passengers following exactly the same schedule. For travelers who have just left the tour bus behind, that is not an obvious upgrade.
Nowhere new to go
Destinations are the other problem. Travelers from China, often short of vacation time, prefer short cruises, and short cruises from Chinese ports can only reach a few foreign destinations. Much of Asia lacks cruise terminals. The halt to group tour sales to South Korea, in force since March 2017, removed Jeju and Busan from most itineraries, and cool relations between Beijing and the government in Taipei make Taiwan an unlikely substitute. What remains is mainly Japan’s coastal cities, plus Hong Kong. With so little variety, few passengers have a reason to book a second cruise.
Cruising in China is not finished. But there are good reasons to trade the bullish outlook of the past few years for a cautious one, at least until the 4.5 million target for 2020 looks reachable. Growth in tourism does not follow from official targets. It follows from conditions that let an industry sell what customers want to buy.