Skip to the page

Passport Season

Notes on how China travels

Destinations

Phuket boat disaster could cost Thailand over $1 billion as Chinese visitors stay away

Four weeks after the Phoenix capsized off Phuket, Thailand's tourism ministry has cut its forecast for visitors from China, and the estimates of what the disaster will cost run past a billion dollars.

2 min read

Four weeks after the tour boat Phoenix capsized off Phuket, Thailand is adding up the damage. The Ministry of Tourism and Sports has cut its forecast for Chinese arrivals between July and December by nearly 670,000, to 5.1 million, and said in a statement that it expected arrivals from China to fall by 60 percent in August. Estimates of the spending lost with those visitors run to more than $1 billion.

What happened

The Phoenix sank on July 5 in rough seas near Koh Racha Yai, south of Phuket, while returning from a popular snorkeling spot. Day trips by boat to the islands around Phuket are a fixture of package tours from China, which is why so many of those on board had booked through Chinese agencies. It was one of three boats that ignored a bad weather warning against day trips to the islands. There were 105 people on board, most of them tourists from China. Divers and the navy spent more than a week recovering bodies, some from inside the hull, and the final toll was 47 Chinese nationals. The captain, an engineer and the owner of the operating company have been arrested and are being held while the investigation continues.

Outside China the disaster drew far less attention than the rescue of 12 boys and their football coach from a flooded cave in northern Thailand, which was unfolding at the same time.

A market that matters

China is Thailand’s largest source of visitors, with 9.8 million of the 35.4 million foreign arrivals in 2017, more than a quarter of the total. The ministry’s statement blamed the expected drop on dissatisfaction over the accident, which mainly affects tour groups. Phuket felt it first. Chinese agencies cancelled around 7,300 hotel room bookings on the island for July and August, according to figures reported in the Thai press.

The reaction in Thailand made matters worse at first. Deputy Prime Minister Prawit Wongsuwon blamed Chinese tour operators for the accident, describing it as Chinese harming Chinese. The remark caused anger on Chinese social media, and he later apologized.

Counting the cost

Visitors from China spend heavily on hotels, tours, food and shopping, so a shortfall of 670,000 over six months removes a large sum from the economy, especially in the southern resort areas where group tours concentrate. The figure of more than $1 billion, put forward by a local tourism chief, is an estimate built on that shortfall rather than a count, and the final number will depend on how quickly bookings return.

The ministry still expects more than 11 million Chinese visitors in 2018 and says arrivals will keep growing from year to year. That depends on repairing confidence in marine safety, where critics point to lax oversight of tour boats and to weather warnings that operators, the Phoenix among them, have been able to ignore.

Repair work

Thai officials have discussed waiving the fee for visas on arrival for Chinese visitors, and the authorities have promised tighter safety checks on boats used for tourism. Thailand’s arrivals from China had been growing strongly in the first half of 2018, and the months ahead will show how long a single accident, and the way it was handled, can hold that growth back. For destinations that depend heavily on one market, the lesson extends well beyond Phuket: the response in the first days after a disaster can do as much harm as the disaster itself.