Skip to the page

Passport Season

Notes on how China travels

Travel tech and social media

Sina's Black Cat takes travelers' complaints off Weibo

Unhappy Chinese travelers used to vent on Weibo. Weibo's parent company now offers them a place to file, track and rank complaints.

2 min read

Travel companies in China have a complaints problem. Surveys have put the share of travelers unhappy with a trip at somewhere between 10 and 20 percent, and for years the most visible outlet for that frustration was Weibo, the microblogging platform where a single angry post can spread far faster than any customer service ticket.

Weibo’s parent company, Sina, now wants to turn those complaints into a service. Its Black Cat Complaint platform (黑猫投诉), available as a website and an app, lets consumers file grievances against companies and offers to mediate between the two sides.

Travel near the top of the list

Black Cat covers every kind of business, but travel companies feature prominently. According to the platform, Alibaba’s Fliggy, Qunar and Ctrip drew the most complaints of any travel businesses in the first half of 2018. The recurring issues will be familiar to anyone who has booked a trip abroad: refunds for canceled international flights, tours canceled by operators, and pressure to buy extras once a trip is under way.

The platform says it receives more than 1,000 valid complaints a day and has accepted nearly 60,000 since launch. Only registered users can file. Each complaint is public and searchable, and each carries a status of replied, resolved or in process. Black Cat has publicized cases in which it helped users get money back, including a full refund from Fliggy for a plane ticket that was paid for but never issued.

Ranking the response

Beyond individual cases, Black Cat publishes three lists each month. A red list names companies that handle complaints well, a black list names those that handle them badly, and a third ranks how fast companies respond. The scores draw on the number of complaints, the share answered and resolved, and the speed of replies.

Among travel businesses, Black Cat’s rankings place Qunar, Ctrip and Ly.com among the better responders. Mafengwo, Airbnb and Tuniu sat near the bottom for complaint resolution in the travel category.

Alternatives to a public post

Before platforms like this, an unhappy traveler had two formal routes: go to the company directly or complain through the state. The official channels are the local tourism bureau, the local government, the local consumer protection hotline and the national tourism service hotline, 12301. Travelers have generally reported more success with the national hotline and with direct contact, partly because local authorities can be reluctant to act against local businesses.

Black Cat sits between those formal routes and a post on Weibo. It adds public pressure to a formal complaint, and it gives companies a place to be seen resolving problems rather than only being criticized.

Questions of trust

Not everyone is convinced. Because the platform belongs to Sina, which earns much of its money from advertising, some users have asked how neutral its rankings can be. Others say it got them a refund faster than any other route. Sina has not said how it plans to make money from the service. Whatever the business model, Black Cat fits a wider push in China toward public ratings of trustworthiness, in this case aimed at companies rather than individuals.